Big City Capabilities.
Small Town Values.
Starr Austen & Miller is a unique team of experienced attorneys serving a wide range of clients, from family cases to civil litigation and personal injury. Regardless of legal concern, our clients can bring ALL legal needs to us to find the best solutions.
A Deep Team of Experts Handling Toughest Cases
With 100+ years of experience, we tackle complex cases, from personal injury to fraud and criminal law. Our big-city expertise and in-house research ensure a thorough, strategic approach.
Small-Town Costs With the Advantage of Big-City Talent
Based in Logansport, we offer top-tier legal representation at rates up to 25% lower than big-city firms—helping clients save without compromising on quality or expertise.
Building Meaningful Client Relationships That Last
More than just litigators, we prioritize communication, shared insights, and ongoing support—ensuring our clients are always informed, protected, and prepared for what’s ahead.
Advocates on Both Sides of the Courtroom
Whether representing plaintiffs seeking justice or defending clients against claims, we bring strategic expertise to every case. Our balanced approach ensures fairness, thoughtful advocacy, and a deep understanding of both sides of the legal process.
Committed to Your Case with No Upfront Fees
Justice shouldn’t come with a financial burden. That’s why, in most cases, we work on a contingency basis—meaning you don’t pay attorney fees unless we win your case. Your success is our priority, and we’re committed to earning our fee by delivering results.
When You Need Solutions,
We Are Here to Help
Scott L. Starr
A partner at Starr Austen & Miller LLP, Scott graduated from Ball State University summa cum laude, majoring in accounting. Scott also graduated, magna cum laude from Indiana University School of Law, Indianapolis. Since graduation, he has concentrated on litigating civil lawsuits, including class actions and various types of securities fraud.
Scott has participated in many jury trials and has acted as class counsel on a number of class actions. He has represented more than 1,500 clients in pursuing claims arising from investment fraud.
Drop Me a Line
Jacob M. O’Brien
Jacob (“Jake”) O’Brien graduated from Indiana University in Bloomington with a Bachelor of Science in Biology, and, later, from Indiana University’s Robert H. McKinney School of Law in Indianapolis, summa cum laude. Jake was sworn in as an Indiana attorney and admitted to practices in both North and South District Courts in Indiana before returning to Logansport, his childhood hometown, to begin his law career at Starr Austen & Miller, LLP.
As an associate, Jake represented plaintiffs and defendants in both state and federal court in a vast array of civil litigation contexts, from personal injury, to complex commercial and contractual disputes and class actions. Now a partner at the firm, Jake litigates a wide variety of complex civil lawsuits on behalf of both plaintiffs and defendants.
Andrew B. Miller
Andrew Miller has been a partner at Starr Austen & Miller LLP since 1996 when he began practicing law. Andrew holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Wabash College and a law degree with honors from St. Louis University School of Law.
Focusing his practice on civil litigation, Andrew has represented various individuals and businesses who have suffered personal or financial injuries. He has handled wrongful death and catastrophic injury cases, stockbroker misconduct cases and complex, nationwide consumer class actions claims.
Mark S. Fryman, Jr.
Mark was born in Indianapolis, Indiana and graduated from Indiana University School of Law, Indianapolis, with a Doctor of Jurisprudence degree in 2003. He has been admitted to the Indiana State, Northern Indiana and Southern Indiana Federal Districts since that time. Mark began his career serving both Marion and Cass Counties as a Felony Deputy Prosecutor from 2003 to 2007, completing thirty felony jury trials.
Mark has focused on civil litigation for Starr Austen & Miller and has tried many cases for plaintiffs and defendants. He has presented at legal seminars for other attorneys and insurance company in-house staff on construction law insurance coverage, personal injury and contractual dispute issues. Mark’s litigation skills have been recognized on the state level.
John R. Janak
Every member of your Starr Austen Miller legal support team adds experience and value to your case. Wherever appropriate our knowledgeable team steps in to speed up your case and keep it running smoothly, while also helping to be more cost-conscious.
Gabriel H. Retz
Every member of your Starr Austen Miller legal support team adds experience and value to your case. Wherever appropriate our knowledgeable team steps in to speed up your case and keep it running smoothly, while also helping to be more cost-conscious.
Hilary Baker
Every member of your Starr Austen Miller legal support team adds experience and value to your case. Wherever appropriate our knowledgeable team steps in to speed up your case and keep it running smoothly, while also helping to be more cost-conscious.
Terri Eaton
Every member of your Starr Austen Miller legal support team adds experience and value to your case. Wherever appropriate our knowledgeable team steps in to speed up your case and keep it running smoothly, while also helping to be more cost-conscious.
Crystal Zinsmeister
Every member of your Starr Austen Miller legal support team adds experience and value to your case. Wherever appropriate our knowledgeable team steps in to speed up your case and keep it running smoothly, while also helping to be more cost-conscious.
Shilby Benn
I have been a registered medical assistant for five years, specializing in Internal Medicine and Dermatology. I have been with Starr Austen & Miller in a dual role as legal secretary/paralegal since December 2024.
Our Latest New
View All News >
Lebanon insurance broker charged in $4M investment fraud
by: Divine Triplett WISHTV.com INDIANAPOLIS (WISH) — A Lebanon insurance broker was charged with six counts of Wire Fraud for a $4 million investment fraud. He was arrested Wednesday and made his initial court appearance in Indianapolis Wednesday afternoon. According...
Kentucky Fraudster is Sentenced to 10 Years for Investment Fraud
A judge recently sentenced Kentucky resident, William S. Evans, to 10 years in prison for bilking a group of his friends, clients, and acquaintances out of more than $17 million dollars with fraudulent promises of high investment returns. Instead of investing his...
Westfield Man Sentenced for Wire Fraud and Money Laundering
BY: Department of Justice, U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of Indiana A Westfield man was sentenced to 5 years in prison for wire fraud and money laundering. He will also serve 3 years of supervised release and was ordered to pay over $1,500,000 in...